• You're one step from joining Cheese Making Forum – DIY Cheese Recipes, Aging Techniques & Equipment.
    Create a free account to post, follow threads, and never miss an update.  Sign up free →

Goat xheddar expanding Uuder wax

Chaplin_

Member
Joined
May 27, 2025
Messages
7
I made a raw goat milk cheddar 2 weeks ago using fresh milk from a trusted source. I waxed it like I normally do, but this time it started to puff up slightly, something I've never seen before. two days ago I saw the wax even split open. I rewaxed it, but now I'm wondering... is it still safe to eat?
 
Unfortunately, it's not safe! That's a strong indicator of unwanted gas production within the cheese. The fact that you've re-waxed it doesn't change what's happening inside. Some cheeses are supposed to puff but that's not normal for cheddar!

In case you're looking into making a new batch, I suggest double-checking your sanitation practices, milk handling, and make sure your starter culture is active and dominant.
 
Unfortunately, it's not safe! That's a strong indicator of unwanted gas production within the cheese. The fact that you've re-waxed it doesn't change what's happening inside. Some cheeses are supposed to puff but that's not normal for cheddar!

In case you're looking into making a new batch, I suggest double-checking your sanitation practices, milk handling, and make sure your starter culture is active and dominant.
I have a friend who would try to save it and even risk eating it, but he's out of his mind. Anyone that's not an ape knows that this should go in the trash because it's the result of yeast or bacteria.
 
Unfortunately, it's not safe! That's a strong indicator of unwanted gas production within the cheese. The fact that you've re-waxed it doesn't change what's happening inside. Some cheeses are supposed to puff but that's not normal for cheddar!

In case you're looking into making a new batch, I suggest double-checking your sanitation practices, milk handling, and make sure your starter culture is active and dominant.
I had a feeling something wasn't right. I'll open it up and toss it if needed, I am going to review my process more closely for the next batch
 
I have a friend who would try to save it and even risk eating it, but he's out of his mind. Anyone that's not an ape knows that this should go in the trash because it's the result of yeast or bacteria.
Yeah, I'm definitely not rolling the dice on this one, it is better safe than sorry, so I'll toss it and treat it as a learning curve for the next batch. Thanks for the honesty
 
Back
Top